Seton Hall's strong defense, allowing just 59.4 points per game (11th best nationally), should keep this heated rivalry game close against Rutgers. Historically, these matchups are tight, as evidenced by Seton Hall's 45-43 road win last year. Rutgers has been inconsistent despite their 6-4 record, with questionable losses like the one to Kennesaw State, and they rank 350th nationally in free throw percentage (60.3%), which could be critical in a close contest. Seton Hall's experienced roster contrasts with Rutgers' reliance on freshmen, giving the Pirates an edge under pressure. With Seton Hall's solid performance in neutral site games and their ability to grind defensively, taking Seton Hall +11.5 is a strong play in what should be a closely contested rivalry game.